Archive for September, 2007

Live @ OMMA: Same Old

Monday, September 24th, 2007

The focus at OMMA and MIXX today is online advertising with a particular focus on web video but most of these guys are talking about mainstream media content. TV programming is what most people are watching and that’s where the money is.

Digital advertising is growing fast, driven primarily by the expansion of broadcast networks and traditional agencies into online space.

There is very little in the way of new ideas here, the innovation talk is of overlay ads and the recurring holy grail of contextual targeting and engagement. The examples used are nothing new. It seems that online ad space is finally approaching some semblance of efficiency if still far from maturity.

At a minimum, it’s not as scary as it once was for traditional players. TV networks are effectively monetizing content online though perhaps not as effectively as they might like. The potential of the medium is understood to the extent that mainstream media is comfortable taking risks because they can put a stop loss on their efforts based on real numbers and a traceable understanding of the cost benefits of online content distribution.

If independent producers and agencies want a bigger share of the online video market to the point where they can actually make money, they will need to focus on quality and create programming that can compete with the content and technological capabilities of traditional networks.

Live @ OMMA: NBC Keynote

Monday, September 24th, 2007

George Kliavkoff, Chief Digital Officer

On Hulu vs. syndication partners:
- Premium content is valuable, “there is a huge value in aggregating content, we believe in ubiquitous content.” If people are interested in multiple content providers Hulu destination site & syndication channels will reach 98% of users.
- Hulu will offer higher quality video, full screen video, possibly a way to take a piece of it with you which you won’t have at syndication sites. NBC is re-skinning the Hulu player for each distribution partner. There are constraints on what can be done on distribution partner sites, no constraints on Hulu.

On Hulu promotion:
- We’ll probably ourselves be promoting for people to go to two places. NBC is giving users the option of where to view content… A recommendation engine will create a loop where someone will watch additional content.

On the Apple fallout:
- We still have a contract with Apple and we were required in the contract to send a notice that we would be leaving or it would have automatically renewed, it’s unfortunate that Apple released a press release, it shouldn’t have become a public thing.”

On targeting:
- The technology is just starting…it’s a little bit difficult because to do that you have to collect a lot of information and you have to be very careful about how you use that information but for us it’s sort of the holy grail and we’re working to get there.
- Web 2.0 has been all about community and social networks, for me the long term of web 3.0 is about predictive marketing. At the end of the day folks don’t want ads that are not relevant. When I’m not in the market for a car I don’t want to look at car ads, if I am in the market for a car I will.

On Long-form content:
- I disagree with the premise that online is about short-form only. The great news is that [users] they sit through the full episode they retain the advertising.

On cannibalization:
- 83% of the people who start watching an hour long episode online get to the end of the last chapter. When people started putting full episodes online there was concern over cannibalization, it actually drives incremental viewership, it’s actually being used as a DVR.
- If we don’t put it online someone else will. If people are going to watch it anyway why not give them a better choice and a fair choice and a legal choice. “Our first run will be successful for a long time but our syndication business may be a point of exposure”

On original web content:
- We actually have been incubating in my group for two years now a digital studio and they sell those in a similar way that TV studios do, we distribute it through portals. I think more and more as we think about how we have to invest in that business…over time we really have to be a content factory that creates content for three screens.

On mobile:
- The revenue distribution model for mobile phones is just broken. The carriers take about 70%, the content aggregators take about 21%, there is no standardization, that leaves 9% for content providers.
- You think about how people consume media on that mobile device and what that device means to you versus what your television means to you…people spend $3.99 for a ten second ring tone that for a computer download would be $.99 for the full song.

On online strategy:
- In the digital world everything you launch is not going to be successful so we need to get comfortable that some things will not be successful, trying to set up the kinds of processes that allow you to fail fast, don’t want to sink a lot of money into it.

On IPTV:
- The promise of IPTV is instant channel change for purposes of our conversation, unlimited channel capacity, highly personal.
- Unlimited programming options. “Shame on us as an industry if we re-purpose our linear channels…we have to embrace all the things these channels can do and program differently for them”

Live @ OMMA: Online Ads By the Numbers

Monday, September 24th, 2007

Geoff Ramsey of eMarketer just gave his keynote, very positive outlook for online advertising growth as you would expect.

Some numbers:
- 69% of U.S. marketers say ROI too difficult to measure.
- 17% of consumers say they have any confidence in advertisers. (Forrester)

Current marketplace: Rock up a hill. Fear of Google. Get Me One of Those (get me a blog, get me a widget). Accountability mandate vs. crisis of trust.

Stagnant radio growth, newspaper growth mostly negative. Growth is in online advertising which will surpass radio for the first time ever in 2007.

- Online ad spending is now about 7.5% of total ad spending.
- 2008 online ad spending expected to be 28.8 billion, 32.8% growth.

Basis for content on the web is shifting to video.
- 65% of all US HHs have a broadband connection.
- Nielsen: Average American views 4.35 hours of TV per day.
- TV audience is 291.3 million monthly, 262.2 million weekly
- 72% of users view online video monthly. 135 million, 47.2 million weekly.
- Average American views 3 hours of online video per month. (ComScore)

$775 million online video ad spending in 2007, expected to reach 4.3b in 2011. Monetization challenge of online video advertising - preserve the control of the consumer: Find more innovative ways of engagement. Overlay ads, Social networking, consumer-generated content, virtual worlds etc.

5 Industry Challenges
- Fragmentation issue: Achieving targeting without sacrficing too much reach.
- Clutter factor: Seek to engage.
- Eroding trust: Focus on suthenticity
- Consumer control: Seek to embed brand in conversations and communities.
- Trend-itis: e.g. Twitter.

Monday Quick Hits

Monday, September 24th, 2007

Here’s what’s happening in online video as we await the morning keynote at OMMA:

  • Micrsoft announced recently acquired aQuantive has signed 20 new clients including AP. “Karl Siebrecht, president of the Atlas business, said aQuantive’s display advertising technology was “suffering from a lack of visibility” before the Microsoft buyout.”
  • The Times slams the WB’s new online video show Online Nation.
  • TNS research announced the results of their AOL/Google Online Video Survey study: 78% Say Online Video Ads Are As Good or Better Than TV to Learn About Advertisers
  • Rocketboom has joined blip.tv and is being sponsored by the Sarah Silverman Program. Those guys at blip have online video sponsorship down to a science.
  • Halo 3 is released. After that death from online gambling last week how long until the first video-game induced death?

The Week Ahead

Sunday, September 23rd, 2007

UPDATED: If you can’t make these, NewTeeVee has a screenings event on Monday night and CenterNetworks hosts an event Thursday evening. Check out our new events section for a running list of what’s happening in New York.

Two big advertising events this week, competing for attention. Silly, I know. Big pain for marketing departments figuring out where to spend some money and for everyone else to split time. That said, be sure to at least drop by the free expo halls.

MediaPost’s OMMA NYC Conference
The Hilton Hotel New York
1335 Avenue of Americas

Great speakers at OMMA, including James Lipton interviewing Carat’s David Verklin, and OVW friends such as Alan Schulman, SVP, Executive Creative Director at imc2; Ian Shaffer, Deep-Focus; Mark Naples, CEO WitStrategy; Dan Rayburn, EVP, StreamingMedia.com; David Berkowitz, Director of Emerging Media & Client Strategy, 360i; Alan Chapell, President, Chapell and Associates; Yoav Arnstein, General Manager, North American Operations, Eyeblaster; and Tom Hespos, President, Underscore Marketing.

And the IAB’s MIXX Conference & Expo
Crowne Plaza Hotel - Times Square
1605 Broadway at 49th Street

Featuring speakers such as Charlie Rose interviewing interactive guru and super-blogger Seth Godin, Arianna Huffington and more OVW friends like AdAge’s Abby Klaassen, Tremor Media’s Randy Kilgore, BusinessWeek’s Jon Fine, Adweek’s Brian Morrissey, Jack Myers, and Yahoo’s Ron Belanger.

Ben and I will both be on hand at OMMA on Monday, so come find us and say hello!

Weekend OVW Picks: Crossing Over

Saturday, September 22nd, 2007

This has been a week full of convergence moments on both sides. Chris Crocker got a development deal. Bill Murray starred in an online short. Amanda Congdon will be leaving ABC to focus full time online video pursuits.


Above: Starring Amanda Congdon

Kathryn Jones’ live online only series 35 debuted receiving coverage this weekend by the Wall Street Journal. The show quickly added chat making the live experience even more engaging for viewers.

Above: 35 Episode 1

Gary Vaynerchuk of Wine Library TV made an appearance on Ellen not long after an appearance on Conan O’Brien.

Above: Gary on Ellen Recap

Innovation and strong content is driving this confluence of old and new media - good content gets noticed. While not everyone with new ideas is getting TV deals right away they are certainly getting noticed. Once a sizable audience is built networks will come knocking.

NFL Turns to Sling For Live Streaming

Friday, September 21st, 2007

SlingMedia has achieved another major deal with a pro sports league following their deal with the NHL in June, this time in a different form. Sling, best known for their devices allowing users to stream their cable box online or on their cell phone will power the NFL’s streaming video as part of the DirecTV Superfan package.

Sling has historically focused on delivering TV content directly the end user wherever they want to view it, bypassing content rights holders much to the chagrin of some including MLB who has threatened suit.

This new direction dealing directly with the NFL for live content legitimizes the company as a serious player in digital media whose technological strengths outweigh the threat.

Though the deal was never officially announced, Sports Business Journal highlighted negotiations late in August. After astute SlingCommunity members noticed the Sling logo on the DirecTV Supercast player the SlingCommunity Blog got confirmation from Dave Zatz.

There is still no official announcement from Sling, DirecTV or the NFL though multiple sources have received confirmation. SAI quotes a Sling source as saying “It is a collaborative relationship. Nothing signed.” Gotta love these quick verbal deals.

The Wild West

Thursday, September 20th, 2007

Sure it’s cliché to call online video the wild west, but it’s also accurate. The online video strategies being undertaken by traditional media conglomerates have been questioned by almost everyone without context. In the Wild West very little context exists.

While CBS has been widely praised for their syndication strategy, it’s not necessarily any better than strategies undertaken by ABC or NBC. The content produced by networks may be good enough to drive viewers to centralized portals with a technologically advanced delivery channel. Hulu’s 50-50 good content goes here portal/syndication model may well be a success simply by virtue of being a recognized brand name for NBC & FOX content online.

Regardless of the outcome, this is a fun industry to be a part of. Everything is evolving so quickly that we need to stay focused on moving forward, not criticizing those trying to find their way. Enjoy it, and lend a hand by joining constructively in the conversation.

Waiting On Silverlight 1.1

Thursday, September 20th, 2007

While Microsoft Silverlight has signed on some pretty decent customers in MLB, WWE and Entertainment Tonight there’s not much momentum driving it toward mainstream adoption.

In an admittedly completely unscientific poll done by TelerikWatch.com 82% of responders said they were “waiting for Silverlight 1.1 before doing any serious development.”

This is after all a Microsoft product, and if they can’t get their latest operating system to work (see: Vista issues) companies are not going to rush into investing time and money on an unproven platform.

Don’t get me wrong, Silverlight has had some good early buzz. Until Adobe lowers their Flash licensing fees Silverlight will be cheaper, and for a company already using Windows Media the switch to Silverlight will be a lot less complicated than another next gen format.

The question is whether it will be adopted once it’s ready to go in a more stable form. Existing Microsoft partnerships will drive development by big companies and it will be especially strong for live streaming, but it’s no “flash killer.”

Both products can do most of the same things, ease of development and business considerations including cost of switching will determine which is used. Silverlight enables Microsoft to stay competitive, but I think it’s unlikely we see many companies currently using Flash switch to Silverlight or vice versa.

The Daily Show on Student Tasering

Thursday, September 20th, 2007

Everyone has an opinion on Andrew Meyer, the Florida student who got Tasered.

Public response in situations like these is usually more moving than the incident itself. This week’s occurrence recalls a similar incident at UCLA last year which prompted a similar student response.

Jon Stewart offers:

“The unfortunate combination of police overreaction and what appears to be student douchbaggery”

That about sums it up.